Reviews

Read what people like you are saying about our revolutionary non-alcoholic spirits.
Our reviews are certified authentic by Judge.Me, the independent service we use to gather reviews.
Certified Reviews
Based on 58 reviews
60%
(35)
24%
(14)
9%
(5)
5%
(3)
2%
(1)
GREAT AS A MIXER

I ordered two bottles and I must say when mixed this product does taste like the real thing but of course without the kick or hangover.

Good non alcoholic option. not much bite, but ok mixed

Have tried product from Free Spirit. It's better straight than Seir Hill is, but this product has a good smooth texture that the other doesn't have, and when mixed (I just used a lightly flavored soda), it works just fine. New to this type of product, so still exploring, but not opposed to ordering this again.

Good

Good, but has no resemblance to the real thing. However, just like the real thing one develops a “taste”for it.

Happy with product looking forward to receiving my new order in July. Thanks.James L.Montford.

Still Learning

I'm just diving into the N/A world...looking for great red wines and bourbon derivatives that can be used to replicate the alcohol-based versions I've enjoyed for decades. Seir Hill is good and I will keep it on the shelf.

C
Mashville™ Non-alcoholic Whiskey Alternative
CLINTON JENSEN (Salt Lake City)
On the right track, but needs improvement

I had a varied experience with this product. You need to be careful with the recipes and reduce the amount of this stuff you add to your drink. When I made my first drink, I didn't measure it and just poured in whatever amount to a Coke Zero. It was awful that first time and I had to get used to the flavor, which is more like rum to me. In any case, after reducing the amount I added to each drink, the taste got better. For example, I only add about one ounce to a 12 ounce Coke Zero, that is the sweet spot and tastes pretty good. Having said that, this stuff could use more improvement on the flavor front, it needs to be more smoky and less sweet. Even so, I give it four stars due to finding a recipe that works for me that I like. Be patient and try different things with it before you write a review. Good luck!

Tasty but not what I expected

The Seir Hill Mashville is absolutely delicious. I like that it’s not sweetened at all, and it has a complex warming flavor. Strong clove and a little citrus and caramel. Very tasty. But it didn’t remind me much of whiskey or bourbon at all. I’m still enjoying it very much but it wasn’t what I expected.

I like it - has a taste all its own

it's a little watery, not as strong as i'd like. it doesn't taste like whiskey, but it has a taste all its own that i like. a spirit-like taste. i wish it had more of a kick and less of a price.

What a great product.

First off, they tell you straight up that this is for Mocktails. Do not try this neat. That said this is fantastic. I think my favorite was a mint julip. Another way I enjoyed this was with a little simple syrup and a bit of water. Great alternative. Fantastic.

B
Mashville™ Non-alcoholic Whiskey Alternative
Barbara Musante (Blairsville)
Trying a new drink!

the whiskey was a wonderful change from just having water! The smoky flavor and smell were there, and not sweet! Amazing!

A
Mashville™ Non-alcoholic Whiskey Alternative
Angela Schlaeger (Minneapolis)
Awesome Alternative

Thank you for this! I am in recovery and wanted something fun for summer! This is perfect and I will order more and more. I’m Gluten Free so N/A beer is out of the question! I drink it over ice or add a little red bull zero for a long night! (Campfires) My favorite part is I don’t fall on my face after!! It has a warm vanilla taste to me that follows with a kick, minus the harsh alcohol sting! Thanks again! ❤️❤️❤️❤️

Drink mixer at best

This is a great addition to drinks but it is not a alternative to bourbon in any way.

Great gift

A relative can’t have alcohol but loves scotch. This was the perfect gift.

Mash

2nd order and enjoy this for a non-alcohol Old Fashion.

Best that's out there.

I love it and would recommend it. Unfortunately so do a lot of people. But it's worth the wait.

R
Mashville™ Non-alcoholic Whiskey Alternative
Richard Jakubczak (Farmington)
Seir hill review

Tried it in a mule, Diet Coke and 7up all were a good replacement for the real thing. The only thing I missed was the hangover.

Very sweet mixer

Whipped up a few mixed drinks with this and it has a very sweet apple taste. Almost tastes like a juice. I like the look of the bottle and that it doesn't have any calories, but it feels like I am drinking juice rather than an alcohol alternative. If you have the Ritual whiskey alternative, they go very nicely together. One shot of Mashville and one shot of Ritual make a nice mixture that seems a bit more similar to whiskey.

S
Mashville™ Non-alcoholic Whiskey Alternative
Stephanie Dumaine (Pittsburgh)
It needs to be mixed with something - does not stand alone

I wish it was bolder, darker and more complex. It is watered down and needs to be mixed with something to make it interesting and tasty. Maybe my hopes were too high for a whiskey alternative to meet. Glad I tried it though.

to me it's a go with actual alcohol. I may very well repurchase

I did not meet my high hopes

The customer service and packaging were great! The bottle and label are classy! Very nice to display. However the taste was not good. I would’ve been ok if it tasted good even if it did not taste like bourbon. But I did not like the taste at all. And it had a very off putting after taste. It is very watery so I am not sure how it will be if mixed to make a cocktail, but I will try it.

Cloudy but fair

I was surprised that it was cloudy! I liked the nose. I thought the initial taste was a little thin. It didn't have a real whiskey mouth feel. The taste was nice, but I really appreciated the aftertaste. It was complex and stayed around for a long time. Thanks, Parker

I was pleasantly surprised

I've given up spirts many years ago, and on a whim I ordered Seir Hill see if it tasted like whiskey, and to me it taste like I remember the leaded stuff tasting, it is worth it

r
Mashville™ Non-alcoholic Whiskey Alternative
robert gitter (Menomonee Falls)
Bob gitter

Best non alcoholic ever had/great customer service/ outstanding!!!!!!

Great

Great as a mixer

While certainly not a replacement at all for whiskey, this is very excellent in mixed drinks by adding a kind of spice taste to them. I had only planned on purchasing one bottle to taste it, but I find I am using it all the time, so I will probably be buying more. Just do not drink this straight, you will regret it.